The National Center for Complementary and Alternative
Medicine reports that 36% of U.S. adults age 18 years and over use some form of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM).
Always consult your health-care professional before
beginning an alternative or complementary therapy.
Historically, traditional Western medicine has
approached healing in just the body or just the mind. It also tends to view the source of a problem as external, in a "disease"
or "disorder" model. For centuries, Eastern medicine has taken a very different direction, viewing the mind and body as unified,
with energy fields both inside and around the body seen as part of the total health system, and approaching healing as an
internal process.
Many kinds of Eastern medicine have begun to find
their way into Western culture. In addition, other non-traditional approaches have become more visible in addressing what
may be viewed as both physical and mental dis-ease. Many are being integrated into traditional mental health settings as their
safety, effectiveness, and scientific validity are recognized.
What is complementary and alternative medicine (CAM)?
The sections below focus on several types of mental
healthcare practices previously considered outside the scope of conventional Western medicine, many of which are now commonly
incorporated in treatment. In general, these approaches may be divided into two broad categories:
- Complementary or integrative approaches (working along with traditional
medicine)
- Alternative approaches (working in place of traditional approaches)
Complementary and alternative approaches often
see life experience and an individual's coping mechanisms as the source of difficulties – that it is not what has happened
to a person that is the problem, but how the person perceives and deals with what happened. It is apparent that what one considers
to be the source of a problem (genetics, disease, internal energy imbalance, or life experience) will affect what treatment
options are considered to manage or rectify the problem.
There are many types of complementary and alternative
treatments, which tend to fall into such areas as:
- Alternative medical systems
- Creative arts therapies
- Nutritional or other "balancing" approaches
- Energy therapies
- Mind-body approaches
Why would someone consider complementary or
alternative treatments for mental and emotional problems?
Most people in our society are familiar with mainstream,
Western medicine. At its best, Western medicine can diagnose and treat many problems that otherwise might cause devastating
effects in a person's health. However, mainstream medicine also has limitations. In recent years, there has been an increased
interest in approaches from other parts of the world, or from other perspectives. Eastern medicine often relies on concepts
that are outside Western understandings. For example, most Eastern approaches view disease or disorders (including mental
conditions) as indication of blocked energy in the body, while Western medicine is more likely to want "scientific proof"
that this energy even exists.
Some reasons people consider complementary or alternative
treatments are:
- Feeling that Western medicine is too mechanical, dogmatic, or compartmentalized
- Belief that Western medicine is fine for what it is, but does not go far enough
- A perspective that the cause of a problem may lie in life experiences, rather
than in genetic defects or diseases
- Concern about the safety of medications, particularly those used to treat
mental or emotional problems
- Seeing CAM as less invasive than Western approaches and wanting to try it
instead of, or at least prior to, seeing a medical doctor
- Objections to what they see as "instant fix-it" or "pill-popping" attitudes
- Being "turned off" to traditional treatments, because of a lack of trust in
doctors, or bad experiences with the medical world
- Religious beliefs that preclude drugs or surgery
- Desire for a sense of spirit or human depth that seems missing in Western
approaches
- Desire for engaging more of the "whole" person in treatment
- Interest in exploring practices that have been in use for thousands of years
in other parts of the world
Most traditional psychotherapy approaches are based
on memory and cognitive reasoning. But current research indicates that the source of anxiety or depression may be unrecognized
trauma in a person's life, and that emotional trauma may result in only fragments of thought or sensations, rather than cognitions.
For this reason, healing – whether from one traumatic event or a series of events – may not lend itself to the
more traditional therapies.
In deciding about the use of complementary or alternative
approaches, an individual or parent should become educated about available options in order to make the best choices for their
particular needs. For example:
- Some might want to see a medical doctor or take psychiatric medication to
relieve the most severe symptoms of anxiety or depression, while considering other alternatives for ongoing treatment
- Some might prefer to avoid physicians and medications entirely and pursue
different means to address symptoms
- Others might want to try a variety of alternative approaches to find a good
"fit" for the specific problems in their lives.
What are some types of complementary or alternative
approaches to mental health treatment?
Alternative Medical Systems
There are many other medical systems in the world,
beyond the standard Western system. Cultures throughout the world have a variety of healers or shamen. These systems are well-developed,
with a 5,000-year old track record for healing, and many are gaining wide acceptance as alternative or complementary approaches
in the West. Each of these systems addresses human suffering in different ways, but generally they seek to re-establish a
balance or harmony within the body and in the lifestyle of the person being treated. Because they tend to view mental or emotional
difficulties as part of a larger matter of balance and overall health, they are included here:
- Ayurveda ("Science of Life" Traditional Medicine from India) is the
oldest medical system. The focus on energy and balance rather than symptoms seeks to restore wholeness in the mind-body-spirit
system. Disease is viewed as an outgrowth of mental conditions. Each person has a particular combination of physical, mental
and emotional characteristics – distinct bioenergetic types known as Vata, Pitta, and Kapha – that are genetically
determined and prenatally influenced. Different causes and treatments of physical and emotional disorders are based in part
on this individual constitution, with the kind of patient being more important than the kind of symptoms. Physical and mental
health is achieved by balancing diet, exercise, sleep, and sexual activity. Some of the tools of Ayurveda include a variety
of stress management techniques, meditation, aromatherapy, yoga, and massage.
- Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), in use for more than 4,000 years,
is based on the flow of vital energy (qi or chi, pronounced "chee") throughout the body. In a healthy state, the yin and yang
(negative and positive energies) are balanced, while a disease state results from an imbalance. Thus, the use of herbs, nutrition,
meditation, acupuncture, and exercise are intended to restore balance and return the body, mind, emotions and spirit to health.
- Native American healing is thousands of years old and combines religion,
spirituality, herbal medicine, and rituals to treat medical and emotional problems, including trauma and addictions. Because
there are hundreds of tribal nations, the practices vary, but generally include purifying ceremonies, chants, sweat lodge,
and other tribal customs. Healing rituals can last for minutes, days or weeks and may involve a combination of dance, chanting,
body painting, and prayer.
- Homeopathic Medicine ("like cures like") was developed n the early
20th century. It does not treat a "disease" or disorder by name (such as depression) but rather by specific symptoms
(including things that affect symptoms, such as sounds, smells, tastes, moods, energy, time of day or temperature when symptoms
are worse, etc.). Small, highly diluted quantities of specific substances are used to cure symptoms which would actually be
caused by larger doses of the same substance.
- Naturopathic Medicine sees physical and mental health as arising from
a healing power in the body that establishes, maintains, and restores health. Many other treatment modalities (such as Chinese
medicine, homeopathy, etc.) are incorporated to support this healing power, along with nutritional and lifestyle changes.
Nutritional or other "balancing" approaches
- Vitamins and supplements: Many people may suffer from
both physical and mental conditions that arise from inadequate nutrition. Nutritional deficiencies often first appear in the
form of mental symptoms. Some researchers believe that the imbalances in the system can be regulated by nutritional supplements.
For example, depression may be caused by an amino acid imbalance or vitamin deficiency. The B-Vitamins, omerga-3 fatty acids,
and folic acid are helpful for regulating stress and balancing mood. St. John's Wort and Kava Kava may help with depression
and anxiety. However, without proper guidance of a nutritionist, these substances may also create serious side effects for
some people.
- Allergies: There are many theories that allergies
to such foods as wheat, sugar, and milk cause or exacerbate symptoms in schizophrenia, autism, anxiety, learning disabilities,
ADHD, and other conditions. Some people find that avoiding these foods, or determining other possible food sensitivities may
reduce symptoms. Other suspected sources for emotional problems are sensitivities to substances such as paint fumes, plastics,
or even electromagnetic fields. Some of these can be avoided, if it is determined that they may be causing emotional symptoms.
- Dietetic changes: Many people find that adjustments in their
diet may affect their mental and emotional health. For example, blood sugar levels have a strong impact on mood and
emotional energy, and can be managed by eating small amounts every few hours, particularly of protein-rich foods, in a well-balanced
overall diet.
- Light therapy: For some people, a lack of full-spectrum
sunlight may cause Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD), and they may best be helped by daily exposure to light from a special
bulb, which is now easily available from many lighting stores. This is particularly useful for those in far northern regions
that do not get sunlight for long periods during the winter.
- Chelation therapy: A synthetic amino acid called EDTA is added to the
blood, where it "grabs" (chelates) onto metallic substances, which are then allowed to wash out of the body. An analogous
process is unclogging a drain by adding a chemical which dissolves the block, and then washing the compound down the pipes.
Patients who have had chelation treatment often notice less depression, more alertness, and better memory. It is speculated
that this improvement results when harmful toxins are removed from the blood stream, thus protecting the brain from effects
of these toxins.
- Aromatherapy: The use of essential oils – extracts or
essences from flowers, herbs, and trees – is one of the oldest therapies, dating back 6,000 years to ancient Rome, Greece
and Egypt. These oils are usually massaged into the skin, wafted in a room, or dissolved in a bath. Of our five primary senses,
the olfactory is the only one that transmits information directly from the nose into the limbic center of the brain, the seat
of emotions and memory. Recent brain scan research has shown that different scents affect brainwave production; for example,
with some increasing alpha (relaxation) waves and others affecting beta (alertness) waves. Aromatherapy is effective with
many disorders, including stress, anxiety, pain, PMS, depression, certain types of male impotence, and many others.
- Bach flower remedies: This system is similar to homeopathy, in that
tiny quantities of a plant-based substance are diluted, preserved in brandy, then sipped in water. There are 38 different
flower essences and one combination known as Rescue Remedy. The remedies are used for a variety of emotional difficulties,
including many specific fears and types of depression, as well as personality characteristics, such as selfishness, intolerance,
and inflexibility.
Creative arts therapies
Creative arts therapies such as dance, music, art,
and drama may help reduce symptoms by providing outlets for expression of emotions. They also offer access to "right-brain"
material – non-verbal, emotionally based – which can be impossible to reach through the traditional talk therapies.
Creative writing using dreams, symbols, and myth can also be a way to process emotional material.
Therapists who are registered in their specialization
have received training in the use of creative expression to assist with mental health issues. Many creative arts therapists
are also licensed mental health clinicians, while others may work with a licensed professional as an adjunct to treatment.
The links below indicate the training programs available to art, music, dance and drama therapists, which can assist you in
understanding what each type of art can do, and how to know if a provider has been certified as a therapist.
Energy Therapies
Energy therapies involve focused attention on the
energy fields that are believed to surround and penetrate the body. Some of these therapies use movement, while others involve
manipulation of the energy field or the body. Still others focus on the electromagnetic fields that are all around us. Some
examples of energy therapies are:
- Qi gong (pronounced "chee kung") is an ancient Chinese system using
movement, meditation, relaxation, mind-body integration, and breathing exercises. The purpose is to improve circulation, balance
flow of chi, reduce stress and anxiety, and restore energy and health.
- Reiki (pronounced "ray-kee") is a Japanese system of transferring energy
from the practitioner to heal the patient's spirit, which leads to physical health. The Reiki Master does not touch the person
directly, but places hands over the body. Reiki also uses distance healing, believing that energy fields in the universe are
all interconnected and thus can be affected from far away.
- Therapeutic Touch is a form of "laying on of hands," which may also
involve the healer passing hands over the body without actually touching it, to detect energy imbalances and re-direct them
through the energy of the therapist. According to the founders, TT is "based on the assumptions that human beings are complex
fields of energy, and that the ability to enhance healing in another is a natural potential."There are a growing number of
registered nurses who have also been trained in this healing art in classes around the world, who use their gentle presence
and touch to assist patients with many kinds of physical and emotional distress. Skeptics challenge the existence of an energy
field and claim that relief occurs because people feel comforted – to which most healers would probably say that is
not the only reason, but if comfort helps, that's also a good thing.
- The power of the mind – meditation, prayer, and distance healing
are all varieties of thought forms used to calm the mind and body, and to call in a sense of intervention in health from energies
of the spirit. Because stress is at the root of so many physical and mental disturbances – or at the very least, stress
will exacerbate existing conditions – learning to relax the mind and body will ease many symptoms in the mind and body.
- There are many types of meditation that come from various cultural
traditions (Buddhist, Zen, Tibetan, Transcendental, yoga, etc.). In general, they often involve calm and regular breathing,
and a focus on one object (a "yantra" such as a candle or picture), one thought (such as "peace" or "relax"), or one word
(a "mantra," often in Sanskrit or another language) that the mind is directed to return to over and over, and to set aside
other distracting thoughts. With regular practice, one can learn to sit quietly and relax deeply, with a calming result.
- Prayer has been used for thousands of years by every culture. Regardless
of religious tradition, prayer in general reflects a belief that there is a power greater than the individual, and that it
is possible to access that power through words or thoughts. Many people attribute the healing of their physical or mental
conditions to prayer, or to whatever their personal belief in a God or Higher Source might be. There have even been some experiments
that have attempted controlled studies to "document" that prayer works by having strangers at great distances pray for people
in hospitals or with various conditions to see if the prayer group improved at greater rates than the control group. These
studies are controversial, but those who believe in prayer as a healing power would say they do not need a study to know that
it works.
- Others would say that the power of the mind to change the body is evident
whenever someone believes in something, a phenomenon known as a placebo effect. Some will then dismiss the value of
the intervention as "just" a placebo. However, if a belief that something will help does in fact help, it is important to
recognize that what we think or believe has a powerful effect on what happens in our lives. The opposite of a placebo is a
nocebo (Latin for "I will harm"), the effect of a negative belief. The power of an idea to cause healing or harm is
evidence of the power of the mind to lead to outcomes in the body and the overall health. This fact highlights the critical
importance for doctors and others to maintain a positive outlook and not to predict a specific timeframe for the course of
a disease.
Better known mind-body approaches
Some types of mind-body healing have become
so commonplace, and are so often integrated into traditional treatment, that it is difficult to call them alternatives anymore.
Examples include:
- Relaxation techniques or deep breathing
- Yoga or exercise
- Hypnosis
- Biofeedback and neurofeedback
- Acupuncture
Some forms of physical manipulation might
also be considered mind-body treatments, if the practitioner is skilled in connecting the two. Examples include:
- Chiropractic
- Osteopathy
- Massage
- Cranial-sacral therapy
Newer mind-body approaches
Recent developments in the treatment of emotional
trauma include new, highly effective forms of psychotherapy and somatic (body) therapies. Although often intensely interpersonal,
these therapies are also psychological and neurological in their focus and application. This group of therapies relies on
innate instinctual resources, rather than medications, to bring about healing.
These newer Body-Mind Therapies (such as EMDR and
somatic approaches) are discussed in Helpguide's Newer Types of Mind-Body Mental Health Therapies.
Can positive attitudes help treat
emotional problems?
The power of thought was discussed above in energy
therapies. In addition, in some situations emotional disturbances are actually the result of a lack of acceptance of differences.
For example, a person whose temperament is more high strung or more laid back than others in his or her family may be labeled
as anxious or depressed, simply by comparison. Another frequently reported source of depression and even suicide is in families
with a child who does not match parental expectations – who is sensitive when a parent wants toughness, or is fat when
a parent wants thin, or is gay when a parent wants heterosexual, or is more interested in fixing engines than going to law
school. Learning to accept, allow for, and even appreciate differences in family members is sometimes all that is needed to
relieve depression or anxiety.
|